Pre-Incorporation Contracts: A Brief Overview

by Jitender
contract

This article discusses the legal implications of pre-incorporation contracts and their enforceability under various laws in India. It examines the Specific Relief Act, the Indian Contract Act, and the Companies Act, covering key concepts and relevant judicial judgments.

Introduction

When starting a new business, there are several critical steps that need to be taken even before the company is legally formed. Founders, often referred to as promoters, may seek to secure contracts, funding, or essential services. This groundwork is vital for ensuring that once the company officially comes into being, it can operate smoothly from day one. However, the question arises regarding the legal standing of agreements made before the actual company registration.

In India, specific laws—such as the Specific Relief Act, 1963, the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and the Companies Act, 2013—grant some level of legal recognition to pre-incorporation contracts. Yet, it is important to understand that these contracts have particular conditions for enforceability before the company’s formation.

What are Pre-Incorporation Contracts?

A pre-incorporation contract refers to any agreement made by promoters before the official formation of the company. At this stage, the company does not technically exist as a legal entity. According to Section 7 of the Companies Act, 2013, the process of incorporation must be completed for the company to gain legal status.

Promoters may enter into various agreements, such as securing financing, leasing office space, hiring staff, or obtaining licenses, all aimed at ensuring a smooth operational start. However, since the company isn’t recognized legally, these contracts are often considered unenforceable unless certain conditions are met post-incorporation. Nonetheless, the Specific Relief Act allows for the enforcement of such agreements once the company is officially formed.

Background on Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Pre-incorporation contracts are legal agreements made before the actual formation of a business. Traditionally, these contracts presented challenges because, under common law, a non-existent company cannot enter into any agreements. This issue served as a limitation for promoters seeking to raise funds or make initial investments before the company was formally established.

Evolution of Corporate Laws Regarding Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Indian corporate laws have evolved to better address the complexities of pre-incorporation contracts. Provisions in the Companies Act, 2013, and prior regulations offer a framework allowing companies to adopt and ratify contracts made prior to their incorporation. Here, the intent is to bridge the gap between practical business needs and existing legal frameworks.

Additionally, the Specific Relief Act, 1963 provides certain remedies, allowing the enforcement of pre-incorporation contracts under specific conditions, thus moving away from the strict common law interpretation that viewed such contracts as inherently invalid.

Legal Provisions Concerning Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Various Indian laws detail the legal status of pre-incorporation contracts. An overview of relevant statutes is provided below:

Specific Relief Act, 1963

Section 15(h) of the Specific Relief Act

This section allows for the specific performance of a contract which mandates the involved party to fulfill the contract without financial compensation. For a pre-incorporation contract to be enforceable under this section, the company must be legally formed after the contract’s execution, and the agreement must be adopted by the newly incorporated entity.

Section 19(e) of the Specific Relief Act

This provision grants a third party the right to seek enforcement of a pre-incorporation contract if it is included in the company’s articles of association and subsequently accepted by the company. This clause acts as a significant exception to the common law rule that such contracts are unenforceable.

Companies Act, 2013

Section 35 of the Companies Act

This provision imposes liability on promoters for any false statements in a company’s prospectus, which could mislead investors. If such statements are proven false, the securities may become void, and promoters may face legal repercussions. This section plays a crucial role in protecting the interests of shareholders and ensuring accuracy in pre-incorporation contracts.

Section 447 of the Companies Act

This section establishes liability for fraud during the winding-up process of a company, particularly if fraudulent activity occurred during the company’s promotion or incorporation. This serves to protect against any pre-incorporation fraudulent actions.

Indian Contract Act, 1872

Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act

According to this section, a contract is legally enforceable only if formed with free consent, lawful consideration, and a lawful object. Any agreement deemed void under the law lacks enforceability, which also applies to pre-incorporation contracts.

Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act

This section states that the consideration of an agreement is lawful unless it is prohibited by law or against public policy. Contracts made prior to incorporation must adhere to legal norms to be considered valid.

Section 196 of the Indian Contract Act

This provision allows for the ratification of actions taken on behalf of another by an unauthorized person. This means companies can endorse contracts signed pre-incorporation after they are formally established.

Section 230 of the Indian Contract Act

This section specifies that an agent cannot create binding contracts for a non-existent principal. This principle highlights the importance of formally incorporating contracts to ensure they are enforceable once the company is formed.

Role and Responsibilities of Promoters in Pre-Incorporation Contracts

According to Section 2(69) of the Companies Act, a “promoter” includes individuals who have been named as such in the prospectus or those who indirectly manage the affairs of the company. This role encompasses various responsibilities including the formation of financial agreements, lease contracts, and securing initial funding.

Promoters act on behalf of the company they intend to form, entering contracts as representatives, but are personally liable until the company ratifies these agreements. Legal provisions ensure that promoters can have agreements recognized after the company is formed, allowing for potential enforcement of pre-incorporation contracts.

Responsibilities of Promoters

  • Structuring the company for business operations.
  • Maintaining fiduciary duties, acting in good faith and avoiding conflicts of interest.
  • Guiding the transformation of business ideas into formal ventures.
  • Disclosing relevant information to potential investors to mitigate risks.

Types of Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Contracts Binding on the Promoters

These contracts are enforceable against the promoters. They are established while the prospective company remains unincorporated, and the promoters bear personal responsibility until the company is formed and adopts the agreement.

Contracts Subject to Ratification by the Company

Some pre-incorporation agreements are intended to be ratified by the company once it is established. These contracts are dependent on the company’s approval, shifting liability from promoters to the company after ratification.

Contracts That Cease to Exist Upon Incorporation

Certain agreements entered into prior to corporate formation dissolve once the company is formed. Such contracts are often preliminary and are intended to be replaced by more formal agreements once the company is legally established.

Doctrine of Agency in Pre-Incorporation Contracts

The doctrine of agency plays a crucial role in understanding pre-incorporation contracts. Under this principle, an agent can enter contracts on behalf of a principal. In the context of pre-incorporation contracts, promoters act as agents despite the company not yet existing as a legal entity.

Application to Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Because the company that will act as the principal is not formed yet, it cannot bind itself to obligations of the contracts entered by the promoters. Therefore, the legal enforceability depends on the company’s ratification after incorporation. Until this ratification, promoters may face legal liabilities.

Doctrine of Ratification

Ratification entails the company formally accepting a pre-incorporation contract once it is established. This legitimizes the agreement, shifting responsibility from the promoters to the newly formed company, effectively protecting the promoters from post-formation liabilities.

Judicial Interpretation in India

Various judicial cases have focused on the application and interpretations of pre-incorporation contracts. Indian courts typically uphold the principle that a company cannot be held liable for contracts executed before its incorporation, unless specifically adopted after formation.

Court rulings, such as in Kelner vs. Baxter and others, reinforce that promoters are personally liable for agreements made prior to the company’s legal existence, driving home the need for prompt ratification upon incorporation.

Liability in Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Liability of Promoters

Promoters assume the responsibility of entering necessary agreements for business success before the company formation. However, they face personal liability for any contractual obligations if the company does not validate these agreements.

On Non-Ratification

If a company fails to ratify a pre-incorporation contract, the onus is on promoters to fulfill obligations outlined in the agreement. This protects third parties who have placed their trust in the contract expecting compliance.

On Ratification by the Company

Once a company ratifies a contract, it adopts the obligations and assumes responsibility, although the specific effects can vary based on jurisdiction and interpretation of the law. In India, the specific language of the contract and the ratification method will guide the promoter’s continuing liability.

Exclusion of Liability

Promoters may attempt to limit their personal liability by including explicit provisions in contracts that stipulate that they will not be personally responsible if a contract is ratified by the future company.

Post-Incorporation Liability of the Company

When a company is officially formed, it is entitled to adopt or confirm pre-incorporation contracts. Depending on the relevant jurisdiction, this may differ regarding how and when a company is considered bound by these contracts.

Enforceability of Pre-Incorporation Contracts

The enforceability of pre-incorporation contracts heavily relies on whether a company opts to adopt or ratify the terms once it is legally established. A successful ratification results in the company assuming all rights and obligations from the original contract.

Without ratification, promoters in India will remain responsible for contracts signed on behalf of a non-existent company and could face legal repercussions if the company chooses to reject the agreement later.

Remedies and Enforcement Mechanisms

The remedies available depend on actions taken after a company is incorporated. If a company adopts the contract, legal recourse becomes accessible against it should it fail to meet the contractual terms.

Enforcement Against Promoters

If the company does not ratify a pre-incorporation contract, third parties may seek legal action against the promoters, who are personally accountable for fulfilling obligations outlined in the contract.

Enforcement Against the Company

Once the company adopts a pre-incorporation contract, it becomes responsible as if it had been a party from the outset. Third parties can then pursue legal action against the company for any breach of contract.

Novation as an Enforcement Mechanism

In cases where ratification isn’t feasible, novation allows for the creation of a new contract substituting the original, transferring obligations from the promoter to the company. All parties involved must consent to this process.

Equitable Remedies

Equitable remedies can include ideas such as estoppel, preventing a company from denying the existence of a contract if it derived benefits from it, or restitution, which entails returning benefits gotten under the contract to the third party.

Company’s Legal Standing in Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Company Cannot Be Sued on Pre-Incorporation Contracts

As a fundamental rule, a company is not legally liable for pre-incorporation contracts made on its behalf before it existed. Cases in legal history support this notion, establishing that such contracts are unenforceable against the company.

Company Cannot Sue on Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Similarly, a newly formed company cannot legally enforce pre-incorporation contracts against other parties since those agreements were made before its official existence.

Risks Involved in Entering Pre-Incorporation Contracts

Lack of Legal Standing for the Company

A company that has not yet been incorporated lacks the legal presence to be bound by contracts made in its name. Consequently, third parties cannot seek repayment or enforce terms.

Personal Liabilities of Promoters

Should a promoter enter an agreement before the company’s formation and the company fails to endorse it later, the promoter may incur personal liabilities, highlighting financial risks involved in pre-incorporation contracts.

Difficulty in Enforcing Contracts

Due to a lack of legal status at the time agreements were made, enforcing pre-incorporation contracts often poses challenges, leading to potential legal disputes and liabilities.

Uncertainty of Contract Terms

As the business model evolves post-incorporation, pre-incorporation contracts may no longer align with the company’s objectives, resulting in disputes over terms and implications.

Potential for Disputes

Engaging in pre-incorporation contracts can open the door to disputes about legal enforceability and contract terms. As the company grows, unresolved issues may lead to further complications if not documented properly.

Tips for Drafting Effective Pre-Incorporation Agreements

In drafting these contracts, it’s critical to ensure clear definition of terms, responsibilities, and potential liabilities. Below are key clauses to consider:

Definitions Clause

This section should define all critical terms used in the contract, particularly “promoter” and “company,” ensuring clarity for all parties involved.

Identification of Parties Clause

The agreement must clearly identify all involved parties and their roles, specifying which individuals are acting on behalf of the prospective company.

Objective/Recital Clause

This clause explains the motivations for entering into the agreement, outlining its relation to the business venture. It provides essential context for the contractual obligations.

Scope of Agreement Clause

Detail each party’s responsibilities to avoid misunderstandings regarding duties and expectations during the pre-incorporation phase.

Adoption by the Company Clause

This clause allows for the agreement to be officially approved by the company upon incorporation, shifting responsibilities from the promoters to the company.

Promoters’ Personal Liability Clause

The agreement should clearly state that promoters will assume liability for the contract until it is officially adopted by the company, limiting their exposure to risks once incorporation occurs.

Indemnification Clause

This clause should address any potential claims or losses to the promoters while performing contractual terms before company incorporation.

Non-Liability Clause

The contract must specify that if the company chooses not to adopt the pre-incorporation contract, it will not be held liable for obligations originally set forth.

Termination Clause

This clause should outline conditions under which the contract can be terminated, offering clarity on potential business actions post-integration.

Governing Law and Jurisdiction Clause

Specify the legal framework that will govern the contract, helping to clarify disputes involving multiple jurisdictions.

Important Judicial Precedents

Vali Pattabhirama Rao vs. Sri Ramanuja Ginning and Rice Factory (1983)

Summary

This case revolved around a contract signed by promoters before a company’s incorporation. The court reiterated that pre-incorporation contracts cannot be enforced against the company until it has ratified them post formation.

Commissioner of Income-Tax vs. L.N. Dalmia (1993)

Summary

This case elaborated on pre-incorporation contracts not being legally binding due to a lack of established legal identity before incorporation. Promoters must accept personal responsibility for agreements made prior.

Asian Hotels Ltd., Bhikaji Cama Place vs. D.D.A. (1998)

Summary

This decision upheld the validity of pre-incorporation contracts once incorporated, affirming their ratification and allowing for refunds related to non-violation of contract terms.

Lindsay International Pvt. Ltd. vs. Laxmi Niwas Mittal (2017)

Summary

This case confirmed that pre-incorporation contracts are void until ratified post-incorporation, highlighting the personal liability of promoters unless expressly stated otherwise in agreements.

Conclusion

In summary, pre-incorporation contracts offer essential benefits during business formation in India. They can be enforced under specific legal conditions as stipulated in the Companies Act and the Indian Contract Act. Understanding and implementing these laws enables promoters to safeguard their interests, mitigate risks, and ensure that once a company is officially formed, all contracts are taken into consideration for smooth operations.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How does a company ratify a pre-incorporation contract under Indian law?

Indian law allows companies, through board resolutions, to formally accept pre-incorporation contracts after their official formation.

Are contracts entered into by promoters binding on the company?

No, unless ratified after incorporation, pre-incorporation contracts aren’t automatically binding on the company, leaving promoters personally liable.

What happens if a planned company is not formed?

If the company fails to form as intended, the enforceability of the pre-incorporation contract depends on its terms and may become void.

What liabilities do promoters bear?

Promoters may be required to compensate for breaches or non-compliance with terms in pre-incorporation agreements if unratified by the company after incorporation.

Can dispute resolution clauses be included in pre-incorporation contracts?

Yes, specifying a preferred dispute resolution process is permissible but must align with legal requirements.

Is it legal to circumvent regulations through pre-incorporation contracts?

No, regulatory compliance remains necessary, regardless of any agreements made pre-incorporation.

Should exit strategies be included in pre-incorporation contracts?

Yes, exit strategy provisions can be part of pre-incorporation contracts, detailing how exits will be handled post-incorporation.

You may also like